Choose the Best Roofing Material in Minutes (A Comparison Guide)

Have you traveled to a foreign land for the very first time and felt panicky inside? Just imagine being in that situation. At that moment, the only thing you’ll ever want in order to survive is a helpful guide.

The same thing happens when you’re a homeowner. To compare roofing materials, you want a useful resource to tell you which one to pick based on various factors. That can be price, appeal, durability, and more. We’ll ease the selection process for you.

Related Article: Best Gutters for Leaf Protection

Just read our roofing materials list below. Surely, you’ll find something that suits your preferences. Enjoy!

A Guide to Help You Compare Roofing Materials

1. Asphalt Roofing Shingles

When it comes to price and versatility, one cannot doubt asphalt shingles. They’re true winners. Most homes in the United States use this roofing type. Homeowners are delighted to know that they can pick from a myriad of colors and designs. Thanks to manufacturers like GAF and Owens Corning, there’s a shingle roof for every need and budget.

grey colored asphalt shingle material

Asphalt shingles are widely used on American homes.

Many roofing materials in the past end up in landfills. This is not the case at all with today’s asphalt shingles. It has become a common practice to recycle asphalt shingles instead of being sent to landfills. Recycled components are then used to improve road surfaces and driveways.

How long do these roofing systems last? Asphalt shingles have an average lifespan of 20 years. But like the rest of the materials on this list, timely inspections and maintenance are a must to maximize their service lives.

2. Metal Roofing

If we compare roofing materials in terms of fire resistance, you’d appreciate a metal roof. They’re rated Class A which means that metal roofs don’t ignite. Some homeowners don’t choose metal roofs because they don’t add dimension. However, try looking through metal roofing product catalogs. You’ll be able to pick from a wide array of styles and colors.

Wind gusts that reach 140 miles per hour don’t do damage to metal roofing. Unlike other roofing types in the market, you won’t need to spend a ton on maintenance. But be sure to contact a roofing contractor to inspect it periodically.

For some homeowners, the noise that comes with metal roofing is discouraging. When it rains, you’ll hear water dripping onto the metal surface. What you should do in this case is to install sheathing and insulation – if you can still afford them.

3. Single-Ply EPDM Rubber Roofing

rolls of black roofing material

Modern homes feature flat roofing systems like EPDM.

People who’d like to build a modern-looking house should choose EPDM roofing. Among the various roof shapes, EPDM roofing is to be installed on a flat surface. Made of rubber, EPDM lasts up to 50 years with proper installation and maintenance.

Can you guess what a common challenge is with a flat roof like EPDM? The answer is ponding or pooling of water. As a homeowner, make sure not to create foot traffic as it crushes the insulation beneath and causes low spots.

EPDM looks clean and professional, costs less, and requires minimal installation time. Don’t worry about heat because EPDM doesn’t deteriorate easily even when exposed to UV rays. Colors come in white or black.

4. Slate Roofing Tiles

Want 100% natural stone as your roofing material? If that’s the case, choose slate roofing. Everywhere you look, you’ll notice that slate roofing tiles come in more serious colors. For example, Gray-Green and Grey-Black. They look timeless, making your residence look superb.

How about the life expectancy of slate roofs? Surprisingly, they last up to 100 years. This means that during the entire time you live in your house, you’ll never have to worry about roof replacement.

Fire protection is another strength of slate roofing. Since it’s heavy, it needs more reinforcement. Also, find a certified roofing contractor that’s experienced in slate roofing installation. Otherwise, you’ll end up with a bad job and deal with unexpected damage.

5. Green Roof or Living Roof

gardens on low rise buildings

Green roofs are also called living roofs.

A green roof isn’t actually roofing material – but formally, it belongs to most lists of roofing types. Rather, it refers to a garden installed over a flat roof such as EPDM. Not all homeowners install green roofing because they require a bit of attention. But the major advantage is that you get extra space at the top for relaxation – although decking is the best choice for relaxation space.

Living roofs go easy on the environment. Aside from the fact that they help cleanse the air, greenery absorbs rainwater. What’s more, noise from the outside that enters your home is reduced. Thanks to the sound-minimizing benefit of your roof garden!

6. Cedar Roof Shakes and Shingles

Wooden roofs look great on country style houses. Don’t underestimate cedar roof shakes and shingles. They stand out not just because of their superior beauty but also their resistance against decay for decades. But because they’re made of natural wood, unfortunately, they ignite.

Now you might wonder what how cedar shakes and cedar shingles differ. Shakes are normally manufactured by hand while shingles are produced using equipment. Also, shingles appear to be thinner than shakes.

Homeowners who don’t mind spending on a beautiful roof and deliberately care for the environment will love cedar. Maintain cedar roofing by cleaning it regularly. Cleaning is extremely important for cedar roofs to facilitate proper drainage of water.

7. Clay Roof Tiles

Anyone who’s heard and seen clay tiles need not compare roofing materials. Why? Clay tiles are simply outstanding. Clay roofing appeals to people who dream of Spanish-style houses and want their roofs to last for centuries. Obviously, those who are planning to live in their homes forever and like roofs that increase property value will love clay tiles.

orange clay roofing

Clay roofing tiles have a timeless beauty.

This material comes in different styles and profiles. There’s the Spanish S-Style, Fan Interlocking, or Pan and Cover Style that looks really attractive.

Regardless of what design you choose, look for a manufacturer that provides 50-year warranties. The reason is that clay roofing tends to fade – although there is no question about resistance against temperature extremes.

Over to You

Were you able to compare roofing materials and finally decide on the best one? If you need more help, Amity Home Maintenance Solutions is happy to assist you. Finally, we offer complete roofing and home improvement services. Please check out our projects. Call us at (203) 678-9891.

2019-01-14T13:23:43+00:00June 30th, 2018|Roofing Systems|Comments Off on Choose the Best Roofing Material in Minutes (A Comparison Guide)